Scamming Copyeditors

I have my name up in a database of editors. This has gotten me work once or twice. However, it also opens me up to scams. Often it is easy to tell the scams:

Dear Sir, I have business opportunity for you due to your reputation as businessman.

But sometimes it is more subtle. For example, today I got an email that has been slightly scrambled to protect everyone’s anonymity but that goes something like this:

Dear independent clause, I am looking for virtual editors for my new company. Below is an email that needs to be edited…

So it’s an unsolicited email by a real person (I know, I looked this person up), but there is no mention of pay, and she didn’t even wait for me to express interest before sending me a copyediting “test”. This screams “Hi, I just figured out a way to get some free editing.”

I mostly like copyediting tests. I like that instead of being asked tricky questions about my three strengths and my three weaknesses, they give me a piece of work and say “do it!”. It shows what I can do, not how well I can play the game. But there are a few rules about copyediting tests. As a gesture of faith, they should be short, and they should not be an entire piece. Or if they are, they should already be published. This shows that the test-giver is not taking advantage of free editing services.

I believe I got scammed like that in the beginning of my career. I copyedited an entire memoir piece and then got reinvited to apply for the same job. When I wrote them back saying “I actually already took your test” I never heard from them again.

So, do is this a scam or is this just a beginner’s error?


One response to “Scamming Copyeditors

  1. I don’t know whether it’s a scam or beginner’s error, but the presumption here would be enough to send the email straight to the trash. At least give the editor a chance to respond before you demand she take a test, for crying out loud. Weird.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s