Critical Thinking and Police Shootings

Louisiana is an open-carry state. Alton Sterling had a gun that he never drew. The man was shot by police when he was on the ground.

Justin Cohen writes, “Be aware of a few standard, and racist, media tropes about Black victims. In the wake of police executions, you are bound to hear a few things that distract from the real issues. One of those storylines is that ‘he was no angel,’ wherein the media will outline the various ways in which the victim behaved inappropriately in the past. None of this matters, and it certainly does not change the fact that the police killed the person outside of any legal process. I smoked pot when I was in high school, for example, and if the police used that as justification to murder me, that would be ludicrous.”

I am not a black man selling CDs outside a convenience store in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. I am a white woman who edits from a comfortable home in the fried-chickenless (but liberal) Northern Wastes. Denial is a way that many people distance themselves from a man like Sterling. “He must have done something,” or “He shouldn’t have been selling [possibly pirated] CDs.”

It might not have been legal, but it (as other people have said better than me) is not a capitol offense. I like how Cohen makes the comparison of Sterling being shot to him being shot for smoking pot in high school. It brings the metaphor home. Let’s apply some critical thinking to this situation. We can stop claiming denial that the person somehow brought this upon himself. (And we know what that argument sounds like.)

The right not be killed by the police is a basic human right. The problem is widespread and institutional. It’s not that all white police are racists. It’s that there is a system of laws, media, and entertainment that criminalizes men of color. When a police car passes me in my medium-sized, relatively peaceful town, I do not expect to be harassed. I don’t think I would be that easy in mind if I were black. The next town over is diverse, but mine is pretty white.

A black hoodie and shorts on a small white woman is read quite differently than a black hoodie and shorts on a big black man. And that’s ridiculous. I would crack a joke about how wearing a hoodie (particularly in the Northern Wastes) is  human right as well. But we all know what happened to Trayvon Martin.



3 responses to “Critical Thinking and Police Shootings

  1. I have been told by an academic that the personality profile of cops and cons is exactly the same according to the Minnesota Multiphase Personality Inventory. The MMPI is an assessment of adult personality and psychopathology ( Psychopathology is the scientific study of mental disorders, including efforts to understand their genetic, biological, psychological, and social causes. In other words, it is the study of behaviors that indicate the presence of a mental disorder (

  2. It seems like a growing number of people have given up on critical thinking altogether, as if they believe that the very process is against their best interests. I’m so confused by that, I don’t know what to say. I’m glad you said something.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s